Icardi On Field
Minutes: 1,452
Goals: 19
Record: 8-6-4
Icardi On Bench
Minutes: 618
Goals: 12
Record: 7-5-0
So basically I looked at how many minutes we have played this season with and without Icardi. I looked at how many goals we scored as a team with or without him and also how we were doing in the match with or without him (winning/tied/losing). So if we were winning a match without him on the field and then ended up losing after he came on the field, I counted it as a win without him and a loss with him. That is why the records may seem weird to you. If he played a full 90, nothing is added to the bench stats and if he didn't play at all, nothing is added to his playing stats.
Without him on the field, we have either been tied or ahead during those minutes. For example: Our 2-1 loss to Napoli. We were losing 1-0 while he was on the field, but if you look at just the minutes he was not on the field (the second half) we tied Napoli 1-1.
We average 1 goal every 76.4 minutes with him on the field, we average 1 goal every 51.5 minutes without him on the field. So we have 19 goals while he was on the field for about 1,452 minutes this season. If we played 1,452 minutes without him and kept the same average, we would have 28 goals instead of 19. The 19 goals is also boosted dramatically by the 4-0 games against Frosinone and Udinese...without those 2 games, these numbers would be even worse.
Now, I believe he has the potential to be a great striker and he has shown it in the past, just look at last season, so I think the blame needs to go on Mancini. Yes he has missed some easy opportunities, but I just don't think we are playing the kind of football that is needed to provide him with more chances.