Edson Arantes do Nascimento

Sisenando

Prima Squadra
Prima Squadra
Joined
Apr 20, 2004
Messages
661
Likes
1
Pélé THE GREATEST!

1> He NEVER took drugs
2> He NEVER bacame fat (well, so far at least)
3> He Doesn't score with his hand
4> He expressed honest football, ie, no diving, cheating, etc to gain an advantage
5> He's a Brazilian! We all know Brazilians are better than Argentines in terms of football

If Zidane had bloomed a lot earlier, ie, he was at his peak at the age of 20, i can assure you he'd be my pick for all time greatest player. The only problem with Zizou is that he's too old and can be inconsistent. Rivaldo could be mentioned in the same breath. He is inconsistent and took a while before he gripped the footballing world. In terms of ability, he had what it takes to be the best EVER. For now, it's Pélé! ;)
 

Kato

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Jun 3, 2005
Messages
4,811
Likes
7
Favorite Player
CN69
10 years of FIF
if u ask people what they know Pele for most, then it would be his reputation as a great footballer.. Now if u asked people the same question about Maradona, i'm pretty sure they'd say his hand of god moment, or his drug abuse.. I dont see how people cant class him in the same catergory as the Gobbi dopers..
 

Handoyo

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
25,084
Likes
49
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
Most Important Member
Ah, the classic debates between Pele vs Maradona. Just like the past, I refuse to comment on the debate because I have never seen a full match of either of them. Sure, I have seen some of Pele's repertoir, Maradona's infamous goals vs England and highlights of both players but they are not enough for me to judge them.

What I can say though, is that it is sacrilegous to consider that one is a 'God' compared to the other. Both men are unarguably the icon of the sport and they should be either equal on ability or separated by a very small margin. I personally juxtapose the comparison of those 2 icons to that of, let's say, Shevchenko & Henry. Both players are perhaps Europe's finest forwards and it's just a matter of opinions, favoritism and, to a certain degree, biasedness from the football fans to choose which is better. :D


Hand;)yo
 

Frisko

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
13,287
Likes
27
Favorite Player
El Principe
FIF Special Ones
10 years of FIF
Remember that we judge Maradona after seeing him play in Italy in modern times, while Pele is mostly known for his World Cup victories, but he played in Brasil all his life. He scored over 1,000 goals in his career.

If you watch some tapes, you'll see what kind of genius he was. I've never been so amazed by a player, the way he could just stand still and make those incredible passes, one light touch to release his team-mates. Incredible.

I personally believe that anyone can be a great player, but only great men can be champions. Champions set an example for others, on and off the pitch.

That's why Pele is a champion, Maradona is not.
 

Handoyo

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
25,084
Likes
49
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
Most Important Member
Frisko said:
I personally believe that anyone can be a great player, but only great men can be champions. Champions set an example for others, on and off the pitch.

That's why Pele is a champion, Maradona is not.
Well, I don't know, Pele's viagra advertisement seriously change my view on him. :D But of course, Pele is also active in some charity/organisation stuff as well, to be fair. ;)


Hand;)yo
 

Frisko

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
13,287
Likes
27
Favorite Player
El Principe
FIF Special Ones
10 years of FIF
Pele actually spoke about that ad in the interview, saying that he wanted to help young people who suffer from erectile disfunction to try and get help.
 

Stefan

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
24,043
Likes
4,817
Favorite Player
Zanetti
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
Nobody is debatting that Pele is the better person. He quite clearly is. But Imho Diego was the better player. ;)
 

Pani

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
1,984
Likes
1
Favorite Player
Javier Zanetti
10 years of FIF
Stefan said:
Nobody is debatting that Pele is the better person. He quite clearly is. But Imho Diego was the better player. ;)

Pele is a good person and a good ...actor.

:star: :star: Diego :star: :star:
 

Miki

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 5, 2004
Messages
4,627
Likes
16
Favorite Player
Javier Zanetti
Pani, you were obviously thinking about the show Victory? :D Yeah, that was a good movie.

Ciao,
Tim
 

Frisko

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
13,287
Likes
27
Favorite Player
El Principe
FIF Special Ones
10 years of FIF
By the way, this topic wasn't meant to be about who's the best between Pele and Maradona. People will never agree on that, just look at the "Best Player in the World" thread, there are people who disagree with each other quite badly.

This was about Pele. In that interview he shows how sharp, funny and considerate he is.

Did you see how strict he was with Ronaldinho? I'm sure he's his number one fan but he wants him to keep it real.

Pele's very conscious of the fact that whatever he says will be written and quoted all over the world.

The thought of him playing football with a sock stuffed with newspapers is simply incredible to me, as is the fact that he won the World Cup when he was 17 and he couldn't even speak to his family for a whole day.

If aliens came to Earth, and we wanted to send them representatives of the human race, Pele could easily be the person representing sport. He has the same respect today as he had we he was a player. My grandfather knows who he is, and so will my children. That's not something that happens every day.
 

catanha

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
2,312
Likes
6
Favorite Player
Santigol
Okay.
Its the internet, I don't get upset, we argue about things, don't get fussed. But one thing will always get to me, and that is if people say that Pele is a champion and Maradona is not, I don't wanna to turn the thread into a Maradona vs Pele arguement so I'll keep away this time...but a few things.

1- You're kidding yourself if you believe that Maradona didn't carry Napoli to Italian and European glory, funny how all the Napoli players all say that...they had good players but Maradona put them on his back.

2- Zaidriano, if you believe what you said...then god help you.
- Pele didn't take drugs, true..but did that help Maradona dominate for a decade?
- So what if Maradona became fat? Atleast he isn't the b1tch of FIFA like Pele is? Atleast he doesn't appear on erection commericals. Atleast he doesn't bag his own NT. Plus he's lost most of the weight.
-He didn't score with his hand...OHHHHH wow...one goal, which he was honest with..ran to the English player and said...would you admit it? and the English players didn't respond.
- He expressed honest futebol? Err Pele never got hammered like Maradona did, he would never have faced the pressures and harassment Maradona did. I'd like to see how Pele would've coped with it.
- He's Brasilian? So just because he's Brasilian he's better? Bendejho!!!

Last I'll say, because its a thread on Pele, not Maradona...but you're not only offending Napoli fans when you say things like Maradona is not a champion.
 

Frisko

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
13,287
Likes
27
Favorite Player
El Principe
FIF Special Ones
10 years of FIF
Lol just open a Maradona thread catanha :p
 

catanha

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
2,312
Likes
6
Favorite Player
Santigol
Nah, then it won't be fun hijacking your threads Frisko. LOL.
:dielaugh:
Don't worry, most of my abuse was directed @ Zaidriano....most of it :frustrat:

:p
 

Sisenando

Prima Squadra
Prima Squadra
Joined
Apr 20, 2004
Messages
661
Likes
1
catanha said:
Okay.
Its the internet, I don't get upset, we argue about things, don't get fussed. But one thing will always get to me, and that is if people say that Pele is a champion and Maradona is not, I don't wanna to turn the thread into a Maradona vs Pele arguement so I'll keep away this time...but a few things.

1- You're ....
2- Zaidriano, if you believe what you said...then god help you....you're not only offending Napoli fans when you say things like Maradona is not a champion.


Okay Catanha, to keep it simple, firstly, i never said he wasn't a champion. OK, that's cleared now. Now, you're merely changing this thread into Pélé VS Maradona. What i did was, comparatively, state Pélé's qualifications, as, in my opinion, this thread is dedicated to him. I mean, the thread wasn't "Diego Maradona". This was what I said:

1. He never took drugs

How does this relate to --"Pele didn't take drugs, true..but did that help Maradona dominate for a decade?"--
Where did i say drugs helped Maradona become the "great" player that he was? I'm merely stating that Pele never showed teens and vulnerable fans that he had to resort to drugs. He never tarnished his image with something to fall back on. He was, squeaky-clean, and a perfect idol in the eyes of millions. On the other hand, Maradona showed a bad example to the world, that such an iconic figure as himself had to resort to a disgraceful thing like that. Again, I'm relating to Pele, as a comparative study, NOT amateur dissing.

2.He NEVER bacame fat (well, so far at least)


You replied with --" So what if Maradona became fat? Atleast he isn't the b1tch of FIFA like Pele is? Atleast he doesn't appear on erection commericals. Atleast he doesn't bag his own NT. Plus he's lost most of the weight. "--

What do you mean by calling Pele the b1tch of FIFA? Has he done anything to you to get an indecent comment like that from you? I mean, did he accept bribes? Harm the game in any way? Harm YOU in any way? What makes you say he is a b1tch? I mean, i wrote so many things, but i could never conjure up the courage to actually use a vulgar superlative to describe a former great player. I say, Pele maintains his fitness up till an old age. Why can't Maradona do the same? Pele's "erection commercial", as you referred to in your post, was a public service, and thus helping his society open up and not be ashamed to say, "yes, they do have a problem". Plus, i find your statements in this phrase rather contradictory when you say, "So what if Maradona became fat?" and "Plus he's lost most of the weight." Well, if it didn't matter, what is your point in bringing "Plus he's lost most of the weight." into the post?

3> He Doesn't score with his hand

You replied with, --"He didn't score with his hand...OHHHHH wow...one goal, which he was honest with..ran to the English player and said...would you admit it? and the English players didn't respond. "--

If I were to meet you in a boxing arena, I mean, for instance, we're boxing, and throwing punches at each other, when suddenly, the referee had a drop of sweat in his eye. For that abrupt moment, he takes his concentration off the match and you deliver a real nice kick on the back of my head (i'm letting you be the agressor here, be thankful :dielaugh: ) and i get knocked out. So the referee calls a KO and declare you the winner. A winner by knockout. Yes, so sweet. So, you bend over to me and say, " Wouldn't you have done the same?" I mean, with all due respect, that's rubbish. Firstly, not all minds are as perverted to cheat like that. Not everyone will think of using his hand to score. Like you kicking me in the back of my head, not everyone will resort to measures like that if the values in him tell him that a game should be won fairly and not through cheating. You have a guilty feeling in the back of your mind that tells you that you didn't win. Its just that the other team didn't lose. ;)

4> He expressed honest football, ie, no diving, cheating, etc to gain an advantage

--"He expressed honest futebol? Err Pele never got hammered like Maradona did, he would never have faced the pressures and harassment Maradona did. I'd like to see how Pele would've coped with it. "--

Are you listening to yourself? I mean, how could you say he never got hammered like Maradona did? Are the defenders against Maradona any much more different than those who came up against Pele? This is a very unfair statement which i think is not justified.

5> He's a Brazilian! We all know Brazilians are better than Argentines in terms of football

This statement was meant to be a joke but it seems some take it a little too seriously. I mean, common sense will tell you that this statement is futile. The only statement i agree with you on this particular matter, --"He's Brasilian? So just because he's Brasilian he's better? Bendejho!!!"--


Thus, I stand by my case. Again, i'd like to stress that this post is made with regard to Pele, not as a post against Maradona.

Sincerely,
-= Zaidriano =-
 

Frisko

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
May 11, 2004
Messages
13,287
Likes
27
Favorite Player
El Principe
FIF Special Ones
10 years of FIF
Guys no offence but I would rather this thread not to become a discussion about that drug addict, this is the Pele thread! :mad:
 

Miki

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 5, 2004
Messages
4,627
Likes
16
Favorite Player
Javier Zanetti
Can we all just agree that Pele is the better actor and move on? :D

Ciao,
Tim
 

catanha

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
2,312
Likes
6
Favorite Player
Santigol
Zaidriano, the fact that you think that Pele got just as much harsh treatment as Maradona on the pitch and that you think that there is nothing wrong with Pele bagging out his own NT and that you think he isn't a b1tch of Fifa, says more about you than I ever could.

Continue with your nonsense, last you'll hear from me in this thread of the 2nd best player in the world.
 

Sisenando

Prima Squadra
Prima Squadra
Joined
Apr 20, 2004
Messages
661
Likes
1
catanha said:
Zaidriano, the fact that you think that Pele ...... says more about you than I ever could.

Continue with your nonsense, last you'll hear from me in this thread of the 2nd best player in the world.

I assume that you do not have a case in condemning Pele in an appropriate and just way. Thanks for complimenting Pele on being the 2nd best player in the world. I appreciate and respect your opinion that Maradona is the best player in the world. Just because you think so, doesn't mean that you have to force the idea on me. Forums are an outlet to exchange our points of view, not to force them unto others. I hope this matter is resolved.
Pélé, the greatest player ever, always ;)
 

catanha

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
2,312
Likes
6
Favorite Player
Santigol
Oh I can type a 5000 word essay on why Maradona is better than Pele, and I respect peoples opinions but when you say things like Pele did nothing wrong in baggin out his NT (or ignoring it) or that he was treated just as bad as Maradona, it proves to me you're a brick wall....so tell me the point, mate?
You think Pele is the greatest and won't change your mind, end of.

ps. We'll see how the Brasilians go @ the World Cup. I know Argentina will be up for it.
 
Top