The Overrated/Underrated Game

[minterke]

I've seen this game played on other forums it's a very cool concept. Let me give you an example. I will start off by saying the name of a player who IMO is overrated.

Then another poster will reply by saying an underrated players name who plays in the exact same position as the player I named. For example:

Miike: Didier Drogba (overrated)

Roberto: Lucarelli (underrated)

Ok that was the example here it goes (any questions will be kindly answered) :

Milan Baros over

 

[Handoyo]

Obafemi Martins (Underrated)

Some even consider Drogba to be better than him. :wallbang: I believe that barring Samuel Eto'o, he's the best African striker in the world.

Am I overrating him? :dielaugh:

By the way, we should keep this topic discussion free. If there are too many discussions here, I'll merge this topic with either the Underrated players topic or the Overrated players topic.


Handyo

 

[Gaetan]

Samuel Eto'o (Overrated)

 

[shahz_nerazzurri]

Gilardino (underrated-i dont care if he is from milan, i like him)
Wayne looney (the bggest ovverrated bast*** in the world)
i dont understand this game, we r only talking about a single position, how do we change positions

 

[minterke]

After Handoyo responded me by saying Martins (underrated) Gaetan should've said another position and either Over or Underrated. Then you should've replied to his player and then so forth.

I will start again.

Beckham (under)

 

[Adriano@10]

mhh if u rate him as dm i ll say Emerson (over)
was hard to get one coz i think becks is most overrated player on earth

 

[Cro Nerazzurro]

lampard (overrated)

 

[minterke]

Cuchu (under)

 

[M.Adnan]

Martins - under

Cordoba - super under

Rooney - super super over

Rual - very over

Henry - super super over

Cafu - Nedved - Ibrahimovic - Cannavaro - Del Piero ( now ) - PIRLO ( I say it 10 times aloud ! ) - all of them r fucken super overrated


and Sheva .. he has no talent .. he's just a lucky b***** .. thats why he scores alot .. and this is not good for football ..

 

[minterke]

Martins - under

Cordoba - super under

Rooney - super super over

Rual - very over

Henry - super super over

Cafu - Nedved - Ibrahimovic - Cannavaro - Del Piero ( now ) - PIRLO ( I say it 10 times aloud ! ) - all of them r fucken super overrated


and Sheva .. he has no talent .. he's just a lucky b***** .. thats why he scores alot .. and this is not good for football ..

Although I hate Andriy Shevchenko I'll have to disagree witht that statement.

Gattuso over

 

[Cro Nerazzurro]

Martins - under

Cordoba - super under

Rooney - super super over

Rual - very over

Henry - super super over

Cafu - Nedved - Ibrahimovic - Cannavaro - Del Piero ( now ) - PIRLO ( I say it 10 times aloud ! ) - all of them r fucken super overrated


and Sheva .. he has no talent .. he's just a lucky b***** .. thats why he scores alot .. and this is not good for football ..

I have to disagree too.
henry, cafu and sheva aren't overrated

under - karagounis

 

[Adriano@10]

carvallho - under

 

[Fabio]

John Terry - over

Next up:

Carragher - Under

Did I do it right?

Fabio

 

[Stefan]

The most overrated player of all time Davids beckham. :stuckup:

 

[minterke]

John Terry - over

Next up:

Carragher - Under

Did I do it right?

Fabio

Yeah Fabs correct. David Beckham isnt overrated, he's overhyped but hes still an excellent right midfielder who delivers amazing crosses. People critisize him for playing DM at Real Madrid. You have to realize that it's not his natural position. It's like putting Veron on the wings and saying he sucks.


Huth (over)

 

[catanha]

Eto'o and Shevchenko over?

If you say so

 

[UhUhOleguer]

Milito - under

 

[Cro Nerazzurro]

ljungberg uderrated

 

[Wallace]

Under:
Toldo(Not well known outside Italy)
Cuchu(Obviously)
J.Z(No one knows about our Capitano...no one puts him into their best 11..why?!)
Matrix(This guy did do something good under cuper..our defence didn't really look too shaky)
Montella(A regret..that he never became famous)
Trezeguet (He should start over Henry in France..really..)
Gattuso(Runs a lot and spends lots of energy ever match but nothing in return)
C.Z (He's kinda unlucky..he became very unimportant after cuper's departure)
Canna (No one considered the Italian Captain one of the best defender..?!!?)
Cordoba (Well...it's all his country's fault..only if he was borned in any country in south american BUT coloumbia)


Over:
Beckham(Leave the soccer industry...go where you supposed to go)
Del Piero(He was once good..)
Adriano (Sry guysT_T..i just wondered why he was named Emperor and Ronaldo wasn't in his first year, basically the whole team relied on him)
Buffon (Always lose goals in critical situations..even Toldo was better than him)
Henry(Has he ever played a match in europe?)
C.Ronaldo(Another Denilson)
Terry(With almost 9 other players helping him..he really got nothing much to do in Chelsea..)
Ronaldo(He's lost it now...stop saying he's better than adriano..why do all Soccer Kings go obese?)
Raul(May be it's just Real Madrid..)
Owen(All EPL players are overrated...that's just because there's less Italian soccer match on tv)
Dida(He lose easy goals)
Nesta (May be he's just getting a bit too old..considering he was once the best..but after the disaster in last year CL's final..questions remain)

 

[primo-inter]

Over-rated: Carlton Cole, Raul, Denilson, Marcelo Salas

Under-rated: Fabio Rochemback, Edmilson, Julio Cruz, John Aloisi, Ludovic Giuly, ADRIAN CACERES

and I just have to say something to Sasuke.... "has Henry ever played a match in Europe?" - what a ridiculous statement. He just scored a beautiful goal in a EUROPEAN world cup qualifer against R.o.I to basically put his country into the world cup. He's also scored a hat trick at the STADIO OLIMPICO against Roma and he frankly decimated our defence when Arsenal humiliated us 5-1 in the San Siro. Please think through your comments?