- Joined
- Jan 27, 2009
- Messages
- 28,734
- Likes
- 14,497
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
FIF Special Ones
Most Humorous Member
I said a double pivot with him given a more free role. Similar to Rakitic in the WC. But not as our sole orchestrator deep in midfield. He's a liability simple and plain. Whatsmore he can contribute goals which we badly need.
He is contributing more than most and contributing what others can not, playing in his deeper position. But you said it yourself, he should not be the sole orchestrator.
Consistency is the key defining factor of ability. The ability to do something consistently. Any player in the world can score a screamer from 30m on their day. Any player can score a beautiful free kick or terrorize a defence on their day. The question is can they do it consistently? How about when it's not their day? Or rather, how often can they make it their day? Only then can you say they have significant ability in that area.
Brozovic does not have the characteristics to consistently excel in an advanced position. He might have some good games here and there but he simply isn't built that way as a player. He is, however, built to consistently play as a high level distributor and playmaker on his deep position. The problem, as so many have pointed out, is that both the individuals around him, and the coaching instructions of these individuals, is trash. This restricts his playmaking, makes him do the brunt of the defensive shift, and in turn makes him tired, frustrated and more likely to commit errors. That is an issue to fix, but it's not fixed by changing his position. It's the exact same thing Kovacic went through. He looks up for someone to play the ball to, but there is no one.
Those two headers against Lazio and Tottenham seem to make Vecino think he's an amazing goal scoring midfielder like Lampard or Hamsik. He is not. But nevertheless, he is always so far forward and usually marked, meaning Brozovic can not even pass to his midfield partner. What kind of partner is that? Speaking of midfielders, Valero is having a good season but he does a similar job to Brozovic and there's no need for him to play with Brozovic. He should be his sub (which he is. Spalletti got that one right.) Gagliardini is having an awful season and Spalletti won't give him time even in spite of Vecino's continual horror shows. Joao Mario had a brief comeback a few months back but that momentary motivation looks to have worn off and last night he was the same lax, lazy, overly casual and impotent midfielder who was hated by the fans. The less said about Nainggolan the better.
The fullbacks too, are indescribably mediocre going forward. D'Ambrosio has no pace nor skill nor the linkup ability to actually make any forward plays on the wing. He cannot dribble past players and as soon as a defender stands in his zone, that's it, he can not advance and must pass inside or backwards. Vrsaljko seems slightly faster and more skilled but not by much, and he is permanently injured anyway. Asamoah is hardly spectacular in this regard and he has been woefully inconsistent. Dalbert deserved more chances but last night was absolutely pathetic. He set himself back 5 steps with that trash of a game.
The wingers are, either by build or instruction, very wide. They don't come in very often and Brozovic often has to walk out wide with the ball to distribute the ball to them. That's not even mentioning the form and issues of Perisic, and while the enthusiasm and (usual) sensibility of Politano is appreciated, it seems finally many are coming around to my view that he lacks that cutting edge to ever really be a top level player. I don't even want to bring up our forwards.
So, what options does that leave Brozovic? What options are there for the guy whose job it is to run, cover ground, defend the midfield by himself, make last ditch 1-on-1 tackles and least of all, control and dictate the entirety of our possession play?
I consider myself one of Brozovic's longest and most ardent supporters on this forum, but has been garbage in the past handful of games. That's partly on him, zero doubt about it. But there is no question that he is not only not helped, but is actually being damaged by the team and the setup around him. There's no excuse for the sloppy giveaways in possession he made last night. But if we address the root of the problem, those giveaways were from overly ambitious passes or from desperate attempts to retain the ball. Perhaps he wouldn't have to be overly ambitious with his passes or dangerously desperately to keep the ball if the team (but midfield in particular) was set up more usefully, not to mention filled with better players.