Overrated and underrated

[Devious]

I dont know about over.. but they are so many nowadays.. specially in the EPL and Liga.. they hype their players so much to compare them to the all time legends.. pathetic.

Under: they are many too but I can recall 2 of them now:

Diego Milito, most underrated striker in the world.. and was by Inter fans in the beginning of this season.. but I think they are finally starting to realize how superb he really is.
Cambiasso.. just because we didnt reach CL late stages and also he dont play in the EPL or La liga, he didnt get to be known as players as Essien and Toure(Barca), one of the best DMs in the world right now and probably the best ball-winners and game-reader out there.

 

[Antonio2810]

Bendtner is the most overated player IMHO

 

[Dylan]

Bendtner is the most overated player IMHO

Agreed. If Bendtner can score a hattrick against Porto's defense then I want to see Milito play against them.

 

[drake]

over:

Eto'o

Torres
Pirlo

hahahahahahahaha!! time always prove people wrong or right!!! this post was made in 06, same year he won la liga and was the highest Goal Scorer in spain and he also won the CL scoring the crucial goal in the finals!! how over rated is that? lol

 

[Alex de Large]

Every player is overrated by play at Barça, you should know that, i mean Iniesta>Sneijder for golden ball? if Sneijder was playing there he would have won.

 

[monster09]

Pepe Reina. Number of blunders he has had is amazing still Liverpool supporters think he is the best. Today had a conv with a liverpool supporter (Not Inidan, English resident Scouser) He rated Reina at 40 Million

 

[Suneet]

Yes some Liverpool fans who came here argued that he was a playmaking GK.

 

[monster09]

Yes some Liverpool fans who came here argued that he was a playmaking GK.

sssssssssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!

They will tell he has some 7 assists in 2-3 seasons.

 

[AxigZag.ESIOLAG.]

Rio Ferdinand to me is the most over rated CB of all times! That guy always benefits from Vidic's covering but somehow gets the accolades...

 

[Karim]

He is very good, u can't say that about a guy who played consistently when he played once with the likes of Brown and O'Shea beside him

 

[Native]

OVER:

Iniesta
Messi
Ronaldo
Van Persie
Ribéry

UNDER:

Huntelaar
Robben
Sneijder
Afellay
Stekelenburg

 

[Visca]

Pepe Reina. Number of blunders he has had is amazing still Liverpool supporters think he is the best. Today had a conv with a liverpool supporter (Not Inidan, English resident Scouser) He rated Reina at 40 Million

Reina is quite good, not quite on the same level as Casillas, Valdes, and Julio Cesar, but he along with Joe Hart are probably the best GKs in the EPL right now. And considering Liverpool's position right now, the club's lucky to still have him.

 

[Batman]

Zoran Pandev is the most underrated player ever

 

[Pajo]

Reina is quite good, not quite on the same level as Casillas, Valdes, and Julio Cesar, but he along with Joe Hart are probably the best GKs in the EPL right now. And considering Liverpool's position right now, the club's lucky to still have him.

Valdes?

Reina >> Valdes. Actually, i wont put valdes in the top10..

 

[Domenico]

OVER:

Iniesta
Messi
Ronaldo
Van Persie
Ribéry

UNDER:

Huntelaar
Robben
Sneijder
Afellay
Stekelenburg

Seriously, how is Messi overrated. i mean saying hes the best of all time is definitely overrating him, but come on, he is still the best player in the world. if not who is better?. Robben and Sneijder are rated highly, Huntelaar was a flop at BBilan and Real Madrid and Iniesta is an excellent player.

 

[dynasty27]

Overrated: Milan Jovanovic, Contento, Bendtner, Eljero Elia
Overvalued: Carroll, Bent

Underrated: Vidal, di Vaio, Negredo, Wilson Palacios

 

[monster09]

Reina is quite good, not quite on the same level as Casillas, Valdes, and Julio Cesar, but he along with Joe Hart are probably the best GKs in the EPL right now. And considering Liverpool's position right now, the club's lucky to still have him.

Reina > Valdes who is another overrated keeper.

Cech is also good and wont do any blunders like Reina, and VDS is on top of his game. Because of his age, he wont get mentioned as the best in the league.

 

[Visca]

Valdes?

Reina >> Valdes. Actually, i wont put valdes in the top10..

Well ok they're probably about the same now that I think about it. Both are top 10 to me but also make dumb mistakes from time to time. Who though is better than them besides Casillas and JC? Buffon maybe but he's aging...

 

[Visca]

Reina > Valdes who is another overrated keeper.

Cech is also good and wont do any blunders like Reina, and VDS is on top of his game. Because of his age, he wont get mentioned as the best in the league.

VdS is retiring so I'm not counting him anymore.

 

[Pajo]

Cech, Neuer, Lloris, Akinfeev, Hart, Buffon are all class above Valdes Cant think of others atm, but i am sure there are other better GKs around there

As for the mistakes, oh well, everyone makes mistake, look at Cesar in the two bayern matches...