You can't compare Dzeko to Arnautovic. Dzeko had pedigree that Arnautovic couldn't even dream of. His career and legacy is 20x that of Arnautovic.
Dzeko spent over 10 years in big clubs competing for and winning trophies, playing at the highest level of competition, while Arnautovic is a failed talent who fucked off to China in his "prime" to collect an easy payday.
More importantly, Dzeko was actually an elite player for the vast majority of his career. A former world-class footballer. Arnautovic has never been anything more than mediocre. So, we're effectively replacing a former world class player for a former mediocre player. What is anyone even expecting here?
For me the biggest issue with Arnautovic is what the transfer signals.
Six weeks ago on July 1, we signed Thuram and our strike force of Lautaro, Thuram and Correa was assembled.
At this stage our management clearly decided this strikeforce was not sufficient. In fact, they decided it was
so insufficient that we strategically sacrificed our highly rated goalkeeper to fund an expensive forward reinforcement and agreed a €40m deal for Lukaku.
As we know, the second half of that operation didn't end up happening, though we still sold Onana for the purposes of financing an important striker. Fast forward a few weeks and we've flirted with Balogun, with reports claiming Ausilio is "in love" with the player. We had concrete interest in Morata before he renewed with Atletico. We actually had the Scamacca deal 99% completed for €28m - which is big money by our standards. We seemingly had concrete interest in Taremi as well despite Porto wanting €30m.
All this indicates that despite Plan A (Lukaku) falling through, the general plan to use the Onana money for a starting striker was still in place.
So... what's changed? Our strikeforce still consists of Lautaro, Thuram and Correa. 6 weeks ago, management looked at this trio and said, "This is shit. We need a big signing and we're even willing to sell Onana to make it happen..."
Did they change their minds? Did they suddenly decide that Lautaro, Thuram and Correa was good enough after all?
It's not a question of money. In that time, we signed Cuadrado for free and Sommer for €6.75m. We signed Augusto, completely financed by the Gosens sale, and loaned Audero, but the Onana money is still there. If anything we should have
more money now that we're about to get a refund for Samardzic.
So what is it then? As far as I'm concerned it can only be two things:
- They've completely fucking given up. After getting rebuffed for all the targets I listed before (Balogun, Taremi) and taking massive L's (Scamacca), it seems like they've just settled for Arnautovic - who I'm struggling to even describe as a consolation prize. It seems like Zhang allegedly interfering with and micromanaging management's completely arbitrary fluctuating budget has completely ruined whatever motivation there was to sign a real striker and they've just stopped trying.
- They've decided to do what they always do - which is to kick the can down the road for another day. Signing Arnautovic can be seen as a "bandaid solution." Perhaps management don't like any of the options available and prefer to reassess the striker market in 12 month's time, going with a temporary solution until then.
Firstly, this raises
massive concerns about the quality of recruitment if these are the only forwards they've considered within budget. It goes to show the utter lack of ingenuity and creativity towards solving problems.
Secondly, following this systematic, team-wide downgrading we've just had, who the fuck even knows what our team will look like next season? The only certainty is that it will be even worse again. This expensive debt we're carrying isn't going anywhere.
Most worryingly though, both options 1 and 2 ultimately have the same outcome - which is a complete fucking surrendering of the upcoming season. Both reasons result in us accepting that this is another season as passengers, aiming for no more than top 4 and to make some money from CL revenue and player sales.
If that's the goal here, there are much better ways to do it than buying Arnautovic for literally TWICE his fucking market value.